Current market environment performance of dynamic, risk-managed investment solutions.
By Jerry Wagner
Is the glass half full or half empty?
It’s an old question, usually meant to tell us whether we are optimists or pessimists. But I think it also describes one of the biggest challenges facing investors.
Look at the stock market on almost any given day. One expert sees a buying opportunity. Another sees a market that has gone too far, too fast. The same economic report can be interpreted as evidence of continued growth or a warning of trouble ahead.
The facts may be identical. The conclusions can be miles apart.
And investors are left with two questions that can have a profound effect on their financial futures: Is this a good time to buy or sell stocks? And, perhaps just as important, how do I know whether my investment portfolio is being managed successfully?
At Flexible Plan Investments (FPI), we have spent more than four decades developing ways to address both questions. While there are no perfect answers in investing, we believe there are better ways to approach them than relying on emotions, headlines, or the opinions of market commentators.
Is the market half full or half empty?
I have been investing since the late 1960s. Over that time, I have witnessed enough bull and bear markets to know that investors can find reasons to be optimistic or pessimistic in almost any environment.
Consider a market that has just risen 20%.
The optimist sees a strong market with momentum that could carry stocks even higher. The pessimist sees an overextended market that may be due for a correction.
Now consider a market that has fallen 20%.
The optimist sees stocks on sale. The pessimist sees a bear market that could produce further losses.
Who is right?
Both could be right. Or both could be wrong. The problem is that neither opinion, by itself, tells us what the market is likely to do next.
This is why, when I founded FPI in 1981, I chose to focus on systematic, tactical investment management rather than simply buying stocks and hoping for the best.
Our approach replaces emotional decisions with disciplined investment strategies governed by researched rules.
Rather than trying to forecast the next market high or low, our systems evaluate market conditions and respond to the evidence available. Depending on the strategy, that evidence might include price trends, momentum, volatility, or other measurable factors.
When conditions are favorable, a strategy may increase its market exposure. When conditions deteriorate, it may reduce exposure, move to more defensive investments, or—where permitted—take positions designed to benefit from falling markets.
The key distinction is that these decisions aren’t based on whether someone sees the glass as half full or half empty. They are based on what the system’s rules tell it to do.
Of course, no system gets every decision right. Markets can reverse abruptly. Signals can be misleading. Tactical strategies may underperform buy-and-hold investments during extended rallies or periods of whipsawing prices.
But the objective is not to be right every day. It is to pursue investment opportunities while managing risks that can threaten long-term wealth accumulation and preservation.
What if we don’t know which glass to choose?
Even with systematic strategies designed to respond to different market environments, we still face an important decision: Which strategy should we choose today?
After all, we cannot know with certainty what market environment will prevail tomorrow, next month, or next year. And it is tomorrow’s environment that will determine the results of the investment decisions we make today.
Once again, we face the “half full or half empty” dilemma.
A strategy designed to take advantage of a rising stock market may be ideal if the rally continues. But what if the market reverses? A defensive strategy may protect us when stocks decline, but what if the market keeps climbing?
The prudent answer, I believe, is not to put all our faith in a single strategy or market forecast. Instead, we should diversify among strategies that use different methodologies and are designed to respond to different market environments.
Consider how differently two of our strategies—both available through separately managed accounts (SMAs) that invest in mutual funds or ETFs—have approached the markets in 2026:
• Self-Adjusting Trend Following uses market trends to guide its investment decisions. The strategy uses our Quantified STF Fund (QSTFX) as part of its dynamic, risk-managed allocation.
• Evolution Plus takes another approach. It focuses on our Quantified Evolution Plus Fund (QEVOX), which has ranked first in its Morningstar Tactical Allocation category on its most recent 12-month trailing-return measure. The strategy employs a diversified, hedged approach using multiple managed-futures asset classes. Its investments have ranged across various mixtures of equities, the dollar, gold, bonds, and commodities as it has worked through the year.
(You can follow the changing allocations of our Quantified Funds by reviewing the holdings information published on our website.)
Two systematic strategies. Two very different approaches to the same financial markets.
Which one had the right outlook? The Quantified STF Fund and Quantified Evolution Plus Fund, used by these respective strategies, both produced double-digit returns through Sept. 30, 2026, despite following very different paths.
Performance. The performance data quoted represents past performance. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Current performance may be lower or higher than the data quoted. Investment return and principal value will fluctuate, so shares, when redeemed, may be worth more or less than their original cost. A Fund’s performance, especially over short periods, should not be the sole factor in your investment decisions. For performance current to the most recent month end, call 1-855-64-QUANT.
But which will have the right outlook going forward? That depends on what happens next. And that is precisely what none of us can know in advance.
Each strategy seeks to capitalize on different market characteristics. Each may excel under some conditions and struggle under others.
By combining strategies with different approaches, we seek to reduce our dependence on any single market outcome. When one methodology encounters an unfavorable environment, another may be better positioned to respond.
Diversification does not eliminate risk, and combining strategies cannot guarantee positive returns. But it can help us avoid making an entire portfolio’s success depend on getting one market forecast—or one strategy choice—exactly right.
Instead of choosing between a glass that is half full and one that is half empty, perhaps the better answer is to have more than one glass.
How do we know how full the glass is?
Even if an investor accepts the value of systematic tactical management and diversification among strategies, how can they determine whether the resulting portfolio is actually working?
Simply comparing investment returns with a familiar market index does not necessarily answer the question, especially if it’s the wrong standard.
A conservative investor should not have to match the S&P 500 to be considered successful. Nor should an aggressive investor necessarily be satisfied with returns that exceed a benchmark if more risk is being taken.
What investors really need is a way to determine whether their portfolio is performing as expected, given their personal objectives, risk tolerance, investment strategy, and time horizon.
In 2007, we introduced our OnTarget Monitor to help answer that question.
The OnTarget Monitor provides each client with a personalized benchmark based on the investment strategies selected for the account and the investor’s stated time horizon.
Using extensive Monte Carlo simulations, it develops a range of hypothetical investment outcomes for each client based on their specific risk profile and portfolio mix. These are displayed as colored bands, with the client’s actual portfolio performance represented by a black line.
When that line moves through the green or blue areas, performance is generally consistent with or better than the modeled expectations.
If it enters the yellow area, it may be time to discuss it with the investor’s financial adviser. If it remains in the red area for an extended period, a more thorough review of the portfolio’s strategies may be warranted.
I am proud to report that, as of September 30, 2026, 93% of our client portfolios were in the green or blue zones of their OnTarget Monitors. In other words, more than nine out of 10 portfolios were performing within or above their personalized benchmark ranges.
This does not mean that every portfolio achieved a positive return or that future results are assured. But it does indicate that the great majority were meeting or exceeding their modeled expectations at that point in time.
These projections are not guarantees. But they provide something that ordinary market comparisons often cannot: a personal frame of reference for judging investment results.
(Of special note, in the third quarter, we added OnTarget Monitor color coding for individual strategies to our client statements, rather than just for overall portfolios. This makes it easier to see which strategies are contributing to underperformance or outperformance within each portfolio.)
Instead of asking, “Why didn’t I make as much as the S&P 500?” the investor can ask a more meaningful question: “Are my portfolio and strategies within it doing what they were designed to do?”
That is a much better starting point for determining whether a change is needed.
A disciplined approach to uncertainty
Investors face two fundamental uncertainties: what stocks will do next and whether their portfolios are performing as expected.
Between those two questions lies another important decision: How do we construct a portfolio that can respond to market environments we cannot predict?
At FPI, we address these challenges through systematic tactical management, diversification among different strategies with different approaches, and personalized performance evaluation through our OnTarget Monitor.
Together, these approaches seek to replace subjective judgments with objective measurements.
An investment plan should not be a straitjacket. It should be flexible enough to change when the evidence suggests that a change is appropriate, whether in managing market exposure, selecting and combining strategies, or evaluating an investor’s portfolio.
There will always be reasons to see the glass as half full or half empty. Optimism and pessimism are part of human nature, and neither will ever disappear from financial markets. But successful investing should not require us to choose between the two.
Investors should carefully consider the investment objectives, risks, charges, and expenses of the Quantified Funds before investing. This and other information is in the Funds’ prospectus and summary prospectus, available by calling 1-855-647-8268 or at https://www.quantifiedfunds.com/fund-documents. Read each prospectus carefully before investing.
Flexible Plan Investments, Ltd., serves as subadvisor to the Quantified Funds, distributed by Ceros Financial Services, Inc. (Member FINRA/SIPC). Flexible Plan Investments and Ceros are not affiliated. Advisors Preferred, LLC, serves as investment advisor to the Quantified Funds and is a commonly held affiliate of Ceros.
There is no guarantee that any investment strategy will generate a profit or prevent a loss. An investment in the Funds entails risk, including loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. There is no guarantee the Funds will achieve their investment objective.
Based on total return, the Quantified Evolution Plus Fund (QEVOX, Investor Class) ranked #1 of 241 funds for the 1-year period and #23 of 202 funds for the 5-year period in the Morningstar Tactical Allocation category, for periods ended 9/30/2026. Past results do not assure future performance. Source: Morningstar. © 2026 Morningstar, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Receive weekly market updates and analysis.